Columbus Crew respect their roots

The story of one of the craziest months in Crew history, and the climb from last place to the playoffs.

Columbus Crew respect their roots
Columbus Crew GM Issa Tall introduces Brais Mendez, an incoming transfer from Real Sociedad of Spain's LaLiga, on July 24.

On April 13, 1996, the Columbus Crew played their first game that counted, a 4-0 victory over D.C. United before an inaugural crowd of 25,266 at Ohio Stadium. Since then, the Crew have marked time with many peaks – including trophy-winning seasons and Save the Crew, an endeavor unprecedented in major-professional sports – and valleys – including gut-wrenching losses in big-stakes games, and Anthony Pecourt, the pink-skinned, nepo-baby horse thief.

Yet, in the 369 months since Brian McBride scored the first goal (that wasn't an own goal) in club history, the Crew have never had a month quite like August 2026. General manager Issa Tall transformed his roster with a torrent of transfers and loans, incoming and outgoing. As bodies flew to and fro, there was a sense that the Crew, who'd won MLS Cups in 2020 and 2023, and a Leagues Cup in 2024 – when they were the top-ranked club on the continent – had become unhinged.

There was an interim-not-interim coach, Laurent Courtois, a rotating cast of players and assistant coaches, and a congested schedule that had the metronomic crushing power of a pile driver. Crew-centric social media was alive with calls to put Tall's head on a pike. The franchise has had its problems over the years, but the soccer side of the operation was usually well-run or, at the least, had good intentions. What the hell was going on here?

Shannon Murray coached at the academy and/or second-team and/or first-team levels for the Portland Timbers and Seattle Sounders from 2014 until earlier this year. He arrived in Columbus as an assistant in July to plug a hole in Courtois' staff, a hole left when Henrik Rydström and two of his assistants were fired in May. It was like parachuting into a stock-market crash.

"(W)hen you look back ... look at where we came from ... that's crazy," Murray said recently.

Counting his time as a coach education specialist with the national federation, Murray has been plugged into MLS for more than 15 years. He had never seen a summer-transfer turnover like the one Tall was handing over to the coaching staff.

"No. Definitely not," Murray said. "... A 16-player change is a massive change. That's a reboot. And to do it in the middle of a season is that much more challenging. But also, it was kind of exciting. Because it was a fresh start."

Courtois is a product of the Lyon Academy, which puts results in the background while emphasizing individual technical ability, positional flexibility and tactical elasticity. The Crew punched the clock, took their lumps, punched the clock, played every third day, punched the clock, traveled, punched the clock, went back to the magnet board at training. What did they do well? What could they clean up? What could they capitalize on?

Who were they?

On Aug. 30, the Crew, at home in Columbus, were beaten 3-1 by the New England Revolution. The Crew were booed by the Nordecke – not lustily, but it was more than a smattering. It was their fourth consecutive loss in league play and it extended their winless streak in all competitions to six games.

Even Courtois, who strives to seek light, acknowledged that the performance against New England was "a big disappointment." If you heard how he said it, you'd have a more fulsome understanding of how big. His team disappeared as the game got tougher.

As August ended, the Crew's record stood at 5-12-5. They were in last place in the Eastern Conference and they had the second-worst record in the league.

Who were they?

From the beginning of September until last day of the regular season, Decision Day, Nov. 7, the Crew posted a 10-3-1 record in all competitions. They won a U.S. Open Cup semifinal on Sept. 16, which propelled them. They dominated and lost a USOC final on kicks on Oct. 26, which could have gutted them.

In league play, the Crew went 8-1 with 24 goals for and 10 goals against over their last nine games. They went 4-1 on the road and, along the way, beat Cincinnati 2-0 in a Hell is Real derby-darby down there near Kentucky.

From 15th place, they hurtled to seventh place to earn a first-round, best-of-three playoff matchup against mighty Lionel Messi and his Club Internacional de Fútbol Miami goons and whiners.

They talked about how every game down the stretch was a "final," and they played like it. The 8-1 run matched the best nine-game run the Crew have had in their 31-year history, previously accomplished in 1996, when shootout wins counted, and 2024, when they were the club kings of North America.

"'And we have a long way to go, still," Murray said. "We're not there, quote-unquote."


Henrik Rydström in January.

What happened? A lot, beginning with the hiring of Henrik Rydström (on New Year's Eve) and the firing of Henrik Rydström (on May 17). The thumbnail version of events:

Wilfried Nancy, the greatest and most successful coach in Crew history, left in early December 2025 to take a big job with Celtic of the Scottish Premiership. (Nancy lasted eight games there.)

Tall had about a month to identify, interview and hire a new coach. Until he did, he had to slow-walk any winter-transfer ideas because in the Crew-verse, the coach needs to sign off on acquisitions. Rydström had visa issues, and then his father died rather suddenly, and his arrival in the States was delayed.

On one hand, you can call Tall to task for not giving Rydström only 14 games over 136 days to make his mark. I did. Rydström was fired before he even had a chance to impact the roster he was supposed to shape.

On the other hand, you can credit Tall for having the guts to admit he made a mistake, and not waiting around to correct it. I did. That took conviction.

Tall didn't like the look or feel of the locker room under Rydström, who thought the team was soft and, as the story goes, had a thousand meetings to discuss this and other matters. I've speculated that one of Rydström's assistants, Theo Olsson, was not a player favorite, and that Rydström's four-back system was a poor fit that did not inspire confidence among his charges.

In any case, on May 16, after a 1-1 draw to Philadelphia dropped the Crew to 3-7-4, Tall walked into the locker room and didn't like what he saw or felt.

"It's fair to say that Philadelphia was the confirmation of it all, but it was the weeks leading into Philly," Tall said. "The moment we made the change, you can tell there was a weight off people's shoulders. And again, there was nothing toxic. I don't want to sit here and say it was hell. It was just that something wasn't right, at all.

"As soon as we made the decision, you could tell right away that training was different, the mood was different, and it showed in those two games before the break. I still believe Henrik is a good coach, it's just that it wasn't a good fit."

Courtois – who won a trophy as Crew 2 coach in 2022, got the dysfunctional Montreal CFs into the playoffs in 2024 and might have (nudge-nudge) been lured back to Columbus in part as a contingency in the case that Rydström didn't fit – took over as interim-not-interim. The Crew shut out NYCFC in a USOC quarterfinal in Columbus on May 20 and then clean-sheeted Atlanta in a league match on May 24 before club soccer shut down across the globe for the World Cup.

Veteran defender Steven Moreira was representative in his instant take on Courtois:

"(W)e played a different system, so everyone played in their real position, and just fluidity, joy. You can tell even the fans, we can tell the atmosphere, they really enjoy too, so yeah, I think that was the good job the coach (Courtois) put on us. Just joy, play free and enjoy, that's it."

Laurent Courtois and his magnet board prior to a training session in July.

The summer transfer window opened on July 13, as the league returned from the two-month World Cup break.

By the time the window closed on Sept. 2, Tall had moved six players – including Designated Players Diego Rossi, the team's leading scorer, and Daniel Gazdag, decidedly not the team's leading scorer, and young star Max Arfsten – via transfer or loan.

More strikingly, Tall imported 10 players (depending on how you count), including new DPs Brais Mendez and Santi Rodriguez. The loan of Anass Zaroury was the last paperwork the league rubber-stamped before the window slammed shut.

What is difficult to comprehend is how much work many of these deals require before consummation. The deal for Rodriguez, an egregious example, began with recruitment in February and dragged into first days of September.

His former club, Botafogo of Brazil's Serie A, was technically bankrupt and owed two MLS teams – including NYCFC, for the acquisition of Rodriguez the year before – tens of millions of dollars in unpaid transfer fees.

"It was literally the entire summer where I didn't go a day without talking to the league or NYCFC or Botafogo or his agent," Tall said. "Literally, every single day of July and August I had these conversations. And also, ownership here was asking me about Santi.

"At the time, ownership was asking me what the odds of us signing Santi, and there was a moment when we were at 10%, and we reverted to option B, C and D. Because it wasn't happening. But we are stubborn, and we pushed."

In his debut, Mendez scored on a free kick to equalize in a 2-2 draw in Miami on August 1. At the time, the Crew were 5-8-5 in league play, they were still alive in the USOC tournament and they had Leagues Cup coming up.

The Crew were playing pretty good ball. They went unbeaten in three Leagues Cup group-stage games and made it to the quarterfinals. They had more than a puncher's chance to beat Club America, a legendary Mexican side, but lost 2-0 in LA – a day after flying halfway across the country from Nashville, where they'd gone toe-to-toe with the league's best team.

"The thing that stood out to me the most, and this was during some of the harder games, was the grit," said the newcomer assistant, Murray, "... Yeah, we have all these quality players on the ball, but can we be a little bit more difficult to play against? Defensively, can we be more stout? ... Could we find that mentality to grind games out when we have to?"

Murray saw glimmers in August.

The thing was, the schedule was murderous, the roster remained aroil and Courtois' absolute need to constantly rotate – just to survive – was not conducive to continuity. The Crew played nine games in August, with road stops in Miami, Charlotte, Nashville and LA. They never had more than three days off between games.

Throughout the month, new players were reporting, and each was at a different level of fitness. The churn didn't slow until Rodriguez' 15-hour hop from Rio de Janeiro reached its terminus in Columbus. Rodriguez had his physical, slapped the scorer's table, so to speak, and scored the first goal in a 3-0 victory over the visiting Colorado Rapids on Sept. 5.

Tim Bezbatchenko is president of global soccer for Haslam Sports Group and oversees the operation of the Crew, Crew 2 and the Columbus NWSL team that will come online in 2028.

He said the Colorado game was one of two points of inflection for the Crew.

"I think from there, we did lose a few matches after that, but that match really ... You could see the difference not only (Rodriguez) made, but the players that were coming in (and) getting fit," Bezbatchenko said during a recent episode of The Crewcible podcast. "(You were) starting to see a shift in the belief of this team, in our ability to turn possession into goal-scoring opportunities.

"I think we were one of the lowest in the league in, once we get into the final third – how do we turn it into shots on goal? Right when we add Santi and, obviously, Brais coming in (with him), it was very quickly we looked at each other – even though we aren't getting results right away – (and said), 'Hey, there's something here with this team, if we can just string together a couple of wins, we can make a run."

Tim Bezbatchenko, after returning to Columbus in July.

Bezbatchenko, when he was president and general manager of the Crew, was the architect of teams that won two MLS Cups, a Leagues Cup and a Camepones (!) Cup, and made it to the final of the CONCACAF Championship League. He's the guy who bought out Nancy's contract in Montreal and gave him the stage to rock in Columbus.

From July 2024 through July 2026, Bezbatchenko was the Bournemouth, England-based director of Black Knight Soccer Club, which runs a portfolio of teams in the U.K., France and elsewhere. A Westerville native, he was ultimately lured back home.

Bezbatchenko watched the Rydström hiring and firing from afar.

Not only has he had a close-up view of everything that has happened in the aftermath, you can see his fingerprints here and there. He goes way back with Tall, his erstwhile assistant GM, and he is technically Tall's boss. But make no mistake, Tall has more to do with the shaping of the Crew.

Here's Bezbatchenko:

"People recognize the Columbus Crew for our identity as a club that's in a great city – but not the biggest city. (As) really well resourced – but not the most resourced. (As) playing a certain style, and playing effective football. That's what people are constantly reaching out to talk about.

"Whether you're in Scandinavia, or I'm in England or Scotland, or at Lorient in France, when they know of MLS, they know of the Columbus Crew."

Bezbatchenko, 45, whose family has had Crew season tickets since Day 1 in 1996, says that the Crew's link to "attractive soccer" probably dates to Sigi Schmid, for whom the league's Coach of the Year Award is named, and the MLS Cup-Supporters Shield double of 2008. It continued with Gregg Berhalter in the teens, before he left to become coach of the U.S. Men's National Team.

In other words, while Nancy is the apotheosis of possess-and-attack, Crew style, the roots go deep.

"I don't think we were ever a team that was low-block-counter," Bezbatchenko said.

Under Courtois, the Crew have not only tapped back into their identity, they've expanded it.

"We're a very resilient group," said captain Sean Zawadzki, the first outfielder in Crew history to play every minute (3,060) of the regular season.

"I think that, no matter what, when times get tough, I know this group is ready to go," he said. "I think we saw that in the last month of the season. We're going to put our head down, we're going to work, we're going to grind out results. You know, we can win in many different ways. You saw that in this little run we had. Whether it's at (Cincinnati) – we had three shots, we score two goals – (or) a game like Charlotte – we have 30 shots, we have 15 on target.

"Whatever is ahead of us, we're willing to do it."

Said Tall, "You can tell, even if you don't know a lot about soccer, you can tell the guys are having a lot of fun. And they're entertaining."

I asked Tall if, in the beginning of August, he had any inkling where the team would be on the eve of the playoffs. He said, "Uh ... yes," and then he launched into an anecdote about Disrespected Media:

Tall: "You and I spoke together for about 30 minutes before one of the games. I think it was early September."

Disrespected Media: "And I said I liked your team."

Tall: "You did. And then you told me there are games you need to circle on your calendar, and I said, 'Cincinnati.' And you said, 'No, the Orlando (USOC) semifinal.'

"At that time, we were dead last in the standings and here in my office, on the whiteboard, I had written in French (the word) 'Last.' (That'd be 'dernier.') But I wrote it with a smile just because, well, let's see what we have here.

"You said you liked our team and I said, 'I do, too, and there's a chance we can do something.' Did I expect us to clinch the playoffs before the last game of the season? I don't know. But ...

"Thing is, when you're here every day, when you're in the locker room, when you're in the team meetings ... I'm fortunate to be close to the team and to get a good sense of, 'Do they believe? Is it possible?' They have the hunger and the quality. I saw it. I believed in them, and they proved me right, so I'm really proud of those guys."

End anecdote. This is me talking now. A few things register.

Courtois has done a helluva job, obviously. He has done it with help from a cast of players who were around during Nancy's trophy-winning years – Patrick Schulte, Mo Farsi, Dylan Chambost, young Taha Habroune, Malte Amundsen, Evan Bush, Moreira, Zawadzki, et al. They've all helped welcome, assimilate and acclimate another half of the roster, the newcomers. And among the newcomers are some equally righteous dudes, and here I'm thinking of Andres Gomes, Mendez, Rodriguez – really, all of them – who've prioritized playing and winning the Crew way.

That's a too-windy way of saying what Gomes said as he walked out of the building after the last game of the regular season in Chicago.

"With quality comes confidence."

It just needed a little time.

Traveling Crew fans at the season finale in Bridgeview, Illinois, where the Crew erased three deficits and defeated the Chicago Fire, 4-3, on Nov. 7.

The Disrespected Tip Jar

Thanks for reading. If you're enjoying what you see and you are of a mind, click on the link below and leave a tip. If you've yet to subscribe, consider making a small hop over a paywall. It'll help keep local, independent media disrespected. You can follow me @MichaelArace1.bsky.social. Have a nice day.

Click below to leave a tip. Thanks.

The Disrespected
Michael Arace covers pro sports in flyover country. Welcome to Columbus, the Blue Jackets and the Crew.